Thursday, March 17, 2022

MICHAEL MATHEWS IN BISHOPS COLLEGE's CLASS OF 51's RACE TO 100

 Dear Readers,

Mike

After a year in Post Matric I went to Natal University in Pietermaritzburg to study Agriculture with no fixed idea of what to do afterwards.  Having scraped through Botany, Zoology, Chemistry, and Physics I changed course and went to UCT to complete a BSc degree majoring in Zoology, Botany and History.

Two years at Lincoln College, Oxford followed and these were magical and unforgettable.  I was fortunate enough to have a few games for the University cricket team with the only first-ball duck of many years of playing cricket being a low-light.  It wasn’t too much of a disgrace in that it was against County Champions, Surrey, and it was Alec Bedser (who Don Bradman had selected in his all-time-great cricket team) who had me caught at leg slip off a devilish off-cutter.

In 1957 I married Alice Hofmeyr, her brother Gys had been in Founders matriculating in 1949 having played centre in the 1949 first XV, often rated as one of the really great Bishops rugby teams.  Alice had been head-girl of Herschel in 1953, and taught at the Dragon School in Oxford in my second (calendar) year.  I duly completed a BA hons in Modern History which enabled me to get a job at Hilton College teaching History and Biology. I coached the U14A cricket side which had the highly talented Mike Procter opening the bowling - off the wrong foot, but most effectively.  After two years I returned to Bishops to teach, which in hindsight was probably an error and after two years I answered a Union Corporation (a prominent Mining House) advertisement in the Argus inviting applicants with University degrees for managerial training.

Mike and his wife Alice

To leave teaching was probably a good decision and Union Corporation top managers were very nice people to work for.  Aware that gold had a limited life, the Mining Houses at the time were looking to diversify, as Union Corporation had already successfully done in starting SAPPI.  When the work I did on the proposal to invest in the Durban shipping company, African Coasters, was accepted, I was sent to Durban to work under Murray Grindrod to ‘gain practical experience’.  African Coasters bought out its two rival shipping companies to form Unicorn Shipping Lines; and I stayed for 20 years, ending as Deputy Managing Director.  These were the challenging years of the introduction of containerisation, the revolution which transformed the shipping industry world-wide.  We had some 30 ships and traded from Lourenco Marques to Walvis Bay and established services to Chile, Brazil, the Congo, Mauritius, Sri Lanka, Iran and Israel.  I was then transferred to Grindrod and Company as MD.  Grindrod had several companies: Ships Agents, Stevedores, Sea Freight, Air Freight, Travel and Container consolidators.

For various reasons and at the age of 53 I resigned and took on the task of turning-around Freddie Hirsch, Bizerba Scales, a Cape Town company that was in poor shape.  With the aid of a brilliant Financial Manager we reduced the number of debtor’s days dramatically and soon posted good results. This was a signal to move on and move overseas to run Safmarine’s clandestine off-shore operations in Antwerp.   This involved the cruise ship ASTOR (which we sold to the Russians), 22 refrigerated ships running bananas from the West Indies to the UK, a container leasing company and one or two other shipping ventures. This was the time of heavy boycotts against South African companies and our Antwerp operating companies were all centred in the Caymen Islands where we had to go from time to time for Board Meetings, keeping it all strictly legal and most favourable tax-wise.

Mike speaking to Private Eye Jon Abbott in his hey-day

My final move was back to Durban to head up the SA Sugar Association, which undertook all the common activities of the Cane Growers and the Millers such as the five experimental farms, exports, marketing and liaison with the Department of Trade and Industry where the Minister had to be encouraged to control the tariffs against mainly Brazilian competitive sugar imports. The Deputy-Minister was David Graaff whom I had taught at Bishops. This was the time of great political change in South Africa.  My role included preparing the Industry for the new dispensation and I invited leaders like Trevor Manuel, Alec Erwin, Jacob Zuma, Dr Frank Mdlalose, Dr Ben Ngubane and others to address the Council.

Eventually I retired to Hermanus in the year 2000 where, together with two friends, I was involved in the start-up of the Overstrand Hospice.  After a few years as Chairman I became Honorary Life President so as to be on the letterhead to give credibility to the role of getting financial contributions to purchase properties for the offices and, importantly, for the Shop.   This enterprise has been hugely successful and their free services provide specialist care for an average of 69 terminally ill patients in their own homes at any one time.

Yours,

Mike

 







JULIAN OGILVIE THOMPSON IN BISHOPS COLLEGE'S CLASS OF 51's RACE TO 100

 Dear Readers,

Julian with his mentor
Harry Oppenheimer

(Here is Julian Ogilvie Thompson’s account of his life as only he could tell it. If only we all could have had such a ‘fortunate life.’)

A Fortunate Life

I was born in 1934 and brought up in the Cape Peninsula, joined by my sister Virginia in 1937.  My mother traced her ancestry back to the three de Villiers brothers who came from France in 1689 with the Huguenots and were allocated large portions of Franschhoek. My father’s ancestors came out, presumably from Scotland, in 1809 i.e. before the 1820 settlers.  An ancestor was Mayor of Grahamstown in 1836 and presented Piet Retief with a bible on departure of the Great Trek.  (Commemorated in a lintel above a door in the Voortrekker Monument.)  My father’s father rose to be Chief Magistrate of the Transkei.  My father was a renowned lawyer who was finally appointed Chief Justice of South Africa against the odds.

My sister and I enjoyed all the facilities and beauty of the Peninsula.  She to Herschel.  I after two? years at Wet Pups (Western Province Prep School) to Bishops Prep and then College, absorbing all the Christian ethics and other fine standards of a great school.  I grew too fast and missed my second year at College, thus coming to compete with Christopher Lawrence as I had with Roger Whiting.  It meant I had good friends in two years.

I was particularly influenced by a great Headmaster, Hubert Kidd, an aesthetic classicist.  How lucky to have such a man as Headmaster, there are always enough masters to ensure sport flourishes.  I was Head of my house, Founders, in my last two years and Senior Prefect in my Post Matric Year.  I was fortunate to be chosen the Bishops Rhodes Scholar for 1953.  We had a good XV over four years of whom 6 ? went on in 1953 to the unbeaten U19A at UCT where I spent 9 months before going by ship up to Oxford.

I enjoyed Worcester College, reading PPE, making lifelong friends, playing rugby for the College and the Greyhounds (including in 1954 a tour of Germany including Berlin and twice only for the University plus its tour of Ireland in 1955).  Cricket for the College and the Authentics and I became a member of Vincent’s a sports Club predominantly for Oxford Blues. I was elected to Jim Swanton’s Arabs.  This cricket club was founded by Swanton, a pioneer cricket commentator and one of the best known cricket writers of his day. We skated on the Worcester Lake in January 1954.  I learnt so much from my tutors and built a special relationship with Asa Briggs, later Provost when our Anthony and Katharine went up to Oxford.

In our first summer 3 ODs, Anthony Landsberg, Roger Whiting and I toured France and Italy, camping just anywhere, not in camp sites.  I planned to repeat this in August 1955 when my sister was in England for a secretarial course.  We invited a son of a Rhodesian rancher friends of my parents whom we knew from UCT and he in turn invited Tessa Brand whom he had briefly met through his sister at secretarial college with Tessa.

We hired a Morris Minor (not a Mini), four suitcases and two tents (one large for the boys, one smaller for the girls) on the roof rack, sleeping bags and cooking equipment in the boot.  And so we went across to Munich, down to Venice, Naples, Rome and back through France.  All moods turn up in a month. Tessa and I found ourselves doing things together.  At the end we met Tessa’s mother at Le Bourget and my sister and I dropped the two of them to stay at the British Embassy.  I feared that was that.

Back in England I was organizing a reinstated ball (ultimately at the Festival Hall) for after the Varsity Rugby Match in early December.  My Cambridge counterpart and I would meet in London every other Friday and I would then spend the weekend at Mill Court (Tessa’s family home in Hampshire).  The other weekend Tessa would come to Oxford, happily being able to stay with her great aunt Dolly Feildon at Headington. And so we became engaged.  I got a job with Anglo American at £60 per month (chosen over Goldfields and Union Corporation).  We were married on 24 July 1956 the day the exam results came out and so began 63½ years of a glorious marriage.  Tessa’s father gave us £300 and his father’s Jowett Javelin and we travelled through France and round Spain and Portugal for 5 weeks – all on £300!  I started work in Anglo’s London Office on 3 September 1956.

Tessa was broadly educated.  Cheltenham Ladies College, a very select sort of finishing school in Merton Street Oxford (only 6 pupils, French and German), a trimester at the Sorbonne, the usual secretarial course and the Courtauld Institute’s Painting section.  She was a country girl, hunting and riding.  When we got engaged her mother rushed her to the London Polytechnic to learn “how to run a home without the servants their mothers had”.

Julian's wife Tessa

Tessa had written a memoir for family consumption of her childhood in London, the blitz, the two years in Washington DC (over in a flying boat sharing a seat with her sister, back in a convoy) when her father was head of North American supply for the UK during the war.  Nine months based on our London Office including a month sorting diamonds (at least I learnt the nomenclature), a month or so each in Rowe and Pitman (Anglo’s brokers) and Lazards who were helping train people for the new merchant bank in Johannesburg, U.A.L.

Back to South Africa in the Winchester Castle for a few days in the Cape and then Johannesburg.  Anglo Secretarial Department.  In 1957 we had two spells of 3 months in houses of assistant managers on long leave to the UK and moved into Froome in Atholl, Johannesburg on 1 March 1958 which has been our home ever since.  We were postal vote agents for cousin Oswald Newton Thompson standing for the UP in North West Rand.

Four children – boy, girl, boy, girl have given us so much pleasure and now 12 grandchildren (if only one granddaughter) and one great grandson.

In November 1957 Sir Ernest Oppenheimer died.  Harry Oppenheimer (HFO) resigned as a member of Parliament for Kimberley and returned to run Anglo/De Beers full time.  I was fortunate to be chosen as his PA in February 1958.  Thus began forty years of working for and with a most remarkable man of so many parts till his death in 2000.  What a privilege that was and how interesting.  It was so totally transformative too.  Harry had a profound influence on me.  Tessa and I were privileged to enjoy a great deal of travel with HFO and BDO and family.  I recall India, Israel, Iran, Brazil, Mexico, Australia and Siberia.  We were indeed spoilt and in other ways too.


        In 1964 I moved with Grey Fletcher (Military Cross) from E. Oppenheimer and Son to the Anglo Finance Division where Grey succeeded Maurice Rush who went to head our new Canadian Office.  In the late 60s I succeeded Grey as Anglo Finance Director.  I was spoilt in being appointed a Director of De Beers at the age of 32 in December 1966.  About 1972 I became effectively the co-ordinating director in De Beers (Peter Gush taking over the Finance Portfolio) and building closer relationships financial and otherwise with the De Beers London Office.  The 1970s and 1980s saw long and tedious negotiations, ably assisted by contemporary OD lawyer Pierce Newton King, in Botswana regarding the expansion of Orapa, the opening of Jwaneng and the increase in Government’s shareholding from 15% to 50%.  In the 1970s I also became the Head Office contact for South America where Mario Ferreira was building up Anglo’s interests.  In the 1970s several visits each year to South America, twice a year in 1980s and one week each year in the 1990s.  I tried to visit a project/mine on each visit.

     There was much international activity following Kaunda’s nationalisation of and then paying out for the Zambian Copper Mines, increasing our holding in Charlie Engelhard’s group, the formation of Minorco  (initially in Bermuda later Luxembourg into which all Anglo and De Beers non South African non diamond interests were put), the dawn raid to 26% in Consolidated Goldfields etc.

Because of my involvement with Anglo and De Beers international activities I visited London many times a year (one year 11 weekends part or all at Mill Court, Tessa’s family home in Hampshire.).  Tessa’s sister in whose favour the Dacre barony was called out of obeyance between her and Tessa absenting after her father’s death, was married to William Douglas Home, the noted playwright, which brought a whole new world to our lives and politics to a lesser extent.  We spent many weekends at their home and several Scottish visits together.

HERE'S JULIAN IN HIS BISHOPS 1ST XV RUGBY DAYS
JUMPING FOR THE BALL AGAINST PAARL GYMN IN 1952
(from the book Bishops Rugby: A History by Paul Dobson)
                                                                                                 

I was privileged to develop a special relationship with Tessa’s father, Hon. Thomas Brand later Viscount Hampden (and Baron Dacre) a senior partner and at his death Chairman of Lazards a leading London merchant bank.  THB taught me so much and was a major influence on my development as I plied him with questions.  He and my mother-in-law came to South Africa each year as THB was Lazards representative on the UAL Board which he had help set up.  Sadly he died at 65 in 1965.  Lady Hampden continued to live at Mill Court, Alton, Hants the house they had bought in 1947.  We gradually took over the responsibility and today our eldest son and family live there and our elder daughter and family in the nearby Oast House which we altered for them.  We have our own room etc.

So the 1960s – 80s were very active.  We all worked as a team of friends, if competitively.  At one stage of Anglo’s 8 departments 6 were headed by Rhodes Scholars!.  In the early 1970s HFO instituted an Annual Chairman’s Conference, soon always at Mbulwa near Sabie, at which the Board of Executive Directors and a few others reviewed the Group’s worldwide activities.  Thitherto only a few (HFO, Sir Keith Acutt and Bill Wilson) knew the whole.  Now we all got to know each other so well.  I succeeded HFO as Chairman of Minorco in mid-1983, of De Beers in January 1985 and after OD Gavin Relly’s 7 year chairmanship of Anglo in March 1990.

In the late 90s it was decided to separate Anglo and De Beers management for anti-trust reasons and Nicky Oppenheimer (NFO), HFO’s only son, took the De Beers Chair in January 1998.  I continued as Deputy Chairman. We then embarked on the complicated exercise, led by our Finance Director, Mike King, of undoing the S.A. Mining Finance house structure of tiered holding companies. This enabled us at a cost of “turning a unique mining house into a generic” one to merge Anglo American of SA Limited with Minorco (really Anglo International) as London registered Anglo American plc.  In mid-2000 I handed the CEO ship to Tony Trahar.  In 2001 we thought we had a new Non-Executive Chairman in Gorhan Lindahl but he got caught up undeservedly in the ABB bonus awards scandal and I continued as non-Executive Chairman until November 2002 when Sir Mark Moody-Stuart, formerly Chairman of Shell Managing Directors took over.

I stayed on the De Beers and E. Oppenheimer and Son Boards until NFO took De Beers private in the early 2000s thereby eliminating the 33% each way voting “control” the investors so disliked.

I was honoured and privileged to be a Rhodes Trustee from 2002 for 14 years, then Emeritus for 4 until 2020.  This was fascinating with a most interesting body of Trustees – ex-ministers, senior civil servants, Heads of Colleges etc.  I was also a Trustee for this same period of the Mandela Rhodes Foundation which offers scholarships on the same criteria as R.S to universities in South Africa.  I think I was able to help Shaun Johnson who so successfully built the MRF to set up a sound financial reporting system in the early years.

For me this Rhodes connection had a special appeal as a school’s Rhodes Scholar and, I think, the only person post Cecil Rhodes’ generation to be on the boards of each of his 3 great companies, De Beers, Goldfields and the British South Africa Company (Charter Consolidated).  I had also been privileged to reply on behalf of the scholars (presumably because I was then Deputy Chairman of De Beers) to Harold Macmillan, Chancellor of Oxford, at the dinner in Trinity Gardens in 1983 to mark the 80th anniversary of the scholarships.

From 2002 November Tessa and I had a wonderful 17 years of retirement with lots of travel, golf and more time at the Game Farm which we had bought in 1969 and 71.  The first farm with the proceeds of the sale of the share Tessa had inherited from her father in Hebron, a tree planation run by SAFI and owned by a group from Lazards ‘Private Fortune Department’.

We also took the children and later the grandchildren too on an annual family trip of which Antarctic over Christmas/New Year 2016/17 was the highlight, the East African migration (twice), Galapagos, India, Okavango (twice) and Uganda gorillas are also memorable.

Our visits to the UK were no less frequent but probably longer both at Mill Court and at the Flat in London, that I had bought from De Beers in 1999.  We enjoyed many visits to the opera and the Royal Opera House (originally in the Anglo/De Beers seats) and the English National Opera, dinners with friends etc.  In January 2020 Tessa had a successful heart double bypass operation but later complications set in and she died on 14 February.  We had a service in a nice Anglican church on the Strand and all the children and spouses and several grandchildren attended, Christopher taking the service.

Thus ended 63½ years of a special marriage – 46 years working and 17 in retirement.  Fortunate me.  Indeed a Fortunate Life.

Kind Regards,

Julian. 

Julian's "fortunate life" ended on 11 August 2023. He was 89.

 

BISHOPS COLLEGE's CLASS OF 51's RACE TO 100

 

Dear Readers,

          I’m Jon Abbott, a lifelong story teller and this could be the most unique one anybody has ever written. After this introduction I am hoping to bring you other posts authored by my fellow OD’s. They will tell you what they made of one of the best possible starts anyone can have in life - a Bishops education. It’s something for the relatively few privileged members of our society. 

        It's remarkable that at Bishops we all started this race on the same line but went on to have very different lives. Hopefully my final year colleagues, who might be reluctant to contribute their memoirs, will take this philosophical advice to heart: “Blowing your own trumpet is the most hygienic way of doing it” - JA.

         My last school year seems to have had more than its share of Very Old Boys or Old Diocesans to give them what they would prefer to be called. They all had the benefit of an education for the elite at the Diocesan College, commonly known as Bishops in Cape Town.

Jon Abbott not 
taking any chances

         What really stands out for the 1951 Class is the number of ODs who are in the running to be the first to reach a century being almost 90 now. I accept that this is like no other race as most of them will probably be eliminated before they reach the finishing line, and sadly there’s little they can do to change that.

          A lot of us have had a varied and incredibly good innings already, so it will be even more impressive if one can reach that elusive 100 mark not out. If it’s not me please be sure to let me know who makes it so I can be the first to announce the result on my blog. I am assured that if he is not already a member of the OD Union he will be given free membership for life.

          Because of the unusual feature of this race it has been difficult for me to know exactly who is still in it now, or who has gone to that happier sports field beyond, where everyone is a winner.

          Dedry Weich in the office of the OD Union very kindly gave me a list of my year’s ODs that they still have contact details for. Understandable she is not allowed to give me their email addresses, but she did email them requesting that they get in touch with me. She had addresses for 19 out of 37 on her list whereas I was told there was originally 66 boys altogether.

          The response I have had so far has been disappointing, either I misjudged the interest this would generate or there are survivors too old or too modest to give me their life story in a few hundred words, or............ This has been a bit of a minefield of touchy egos.

Mike

Michael Mathews (aged 88), who was also in School House, deserves special thanks for being quick to pass on his extensive knowledge of OD affairs to an ignoramus like me. He also made a considerable effort to persuade hesitant contributors to let me use their story and he believes there are 36 of us still around.

Mike set the ball rolling with his potted life story. Here's a list  of our OD’s and their occupations that include those who are still with us, and those who are not that he compiled from his memory bank, with the help of the names Dedry gave me. I have also added ones taken from my own research. *The italics indicate the deceased.

Chairman:  Julian Ogilvie Thompson (87) Anglo American and De Beers, also a Rhodes Scholar. He is by far the top achiever of our year.

Architects: Basil Sgoutas (87), Anthony Hockly (88) and Michael Calder.

Authors: David Dallas, Michael Mathews (88) and Neil Huxter (88), Poet and Rhodes Scholar.

Businessman: Michael Mathews (88) who was also an Author.

Conservationist: Bob Murray (88).

Farmers: Ken Saywood (87), John Torr, Godfrey Gird and Ian McGregor.

Hotelier and Farmer: Frank Musson.

Journalist and Private Eye: Jon Abbott (88), an Author as well.

Lawyer: Storm Reilly (87), Bruce Hart (88), Pierce Newton King.

Medical doctor: Steyn Louw.

Men's Clothing Representative: Peter Copeland.

Parsons: Alistair McGregor (88) and Tim Bravington

Professors: Tim Shaw (87) and Adrian Gear (87).

Rhodes Scholar: Christopher Lawrence.

Springbok rugby player: Tommy Gentles.

The ones Mike didn’t know were:  Rowland Thompson, Jeremy Hewett, William De Villiers, Bruce Balne-Hart, David Brink, Donald Ayres, Bob Murray, Michael Elliott, Rory Arnold, Jeremy Twigg, Reyner Body, Lawrence Solomon, Paul Goodlet, Martin Tromp van Diggelen, Reid Howes, Robert Burgess, David Needham, Bob Morris and Neils Hauffe.

Julian Ogilvie Thompson really came up trumps with his "A Fortunate Life." It's something every Bishops boy would have had reason to expect but his was far more exceptional than the rest of us had. 

Donald Goodspeed, John Groves and Tom Morse contacted me as a result of Dedry’s circular email. So that was encouraging until I only got one hit out of these three when it came to getting them to pen me the story of what became of them after Bishops.

Here’s Donald’s perceptive introduction to his contribution:

          “My first reaction to Jon’s request,” he wrote, “was ‘no ways’ am I going to put myself on display. But then, perhaps he is giving us the unusual opportunity to write our own obituary! So ‘OK.’”

           The other two did not see it like that. John sent me an extremely interesting account of his life together with his photograph only to back out at the last minute. Although I had made it clear that what I was writing was for my blog he some how got the idea that it would be restricted to the Bishop's website and would not be available for outsiders to see. It was not as though he had revealed any dastardly deeds in his background that he was ashamed of. I was told to delete everything he had emailed me.

           Tom on the other hand initially thought I was trying to organise a reunion, but when I told him what I was up to he replied: "I cannot imagine anyone would be interested in what I have done."

           Retired architect Tony Hockly also declined my invitation to air his life on my blog.

           Apart from Julian Ogilvie Thompson, Mike Matthews, Donald Goodspeed, I also got a good response from Storm Reilly's wife Patricia. I'll explain this when I post his life story. Then last but no least there's Your's Truly's crazy mix up life.

         I'll welcome late comes, but they must not forget that time is not on our side. 

          There must have been something special in the food for us borders in School House because the majority of these durable codgers in the Class of 51 were in that house.

Things were not nearly as enlightened at Bishops in our day as they have been in recent times. I am sure that like me the rest of our year must have been disappointed to learn that practical sex education classes were only introduced long after we had all left. It’s distressing to think that in my formative years I missed out on what some Bishops boys have enjoyed at the College. No wonder I failed to keep my first two wives happy. “Three,” my present wife of 49 years piped up.

Dream teacher

In 2019 history teacher and water polo coach Fiona Viotti made a huge media splash when she took playing ball too far for a 173 year old Church school founded by Bishop Robert Grey. She resigned after her sexual antics with a matric boy were exposed and it then emerged that she had scored with five other boys between 17 and 18 from as far back as 2015. All the school needed to complete this embarrassing episode was for one of them to have become a father.

The life stories I get will be in posts that follow this one with a heading that begins with the name of the contributor like this: Jon Abbott in Bishops College's Class of 51’s Race to 100.

Best of Luck to all Competitors,

Regards,

Jon

P.S. Here are the links to the life stories of the following:

Julian Ogilvie Thompson (View Post Here)

Michael Mathews (View Post Here)

Jon Abbott (View Post Here)

Donald Goodspeed (View Post Here)

Storm Reilly (View Post Here)

P.P.S. It’s unlikely that you will find any errors in this post or the ones that follow on the same subject, but if you do please be understanding enough to excuse them because of the senility of the writer.

        


  

 

Tuesday, January 25, 2022

ALARMING CONFESSION OF A DENTALWIZE DENTIST

 Dear Readers,

Dr Lambert Greeff

          Everybody needs their teeth fixed at one stage or another, but is this how it should be done?

          At the end of last year I went to see Dr Lambert Greeff a Dentalwize dentist in Cape Town because I felt there was something wrong with a filling at the back of one of my front teeth. It was such a small problem that I saw him because being in Sun Valley he is conveniently close to where we live, whereas our regular dentist is a lot further away.

          He refilled the tooth, took six x-rays around my mouth and told me I needed eight more fillings and I also had a cracked tooth at the back. He then sent a quote in two parts to my medical aid. One headed “Estimated quote fillings” cost R5 570 and the other one “Estimated quote crown” was priced at R5 677.20 making a total of R11 247.20.

          My medical aid was clearly not happy with his x-rays and quote because it asked for “Clear radiographs showing the entire tooth (apex and crown) with surrounding tissue. Motivation (reason for treatment) related to the lower front teeth.”

          In an email I told Dr Greeff that I found it difficult to believe that I needed so much work done on my teeth because, while I might be old (88), I had always had very good teeth and I go to the dentist on a regular basis.

          I added that by chance I saw my GP about an unrelated matter shortly after I had seen him and I asked my doctor, “If you were told by a dentist that you needed 8 fillings and had a cracked tooth, but you did not feel anything wrong with your teeth, would you go ahead with the dental work you were told you needed?” He replied: “I would get another opinion”.

          I told Dr Greeff this is what I did. I went back to my regular dentist with copies of his x-rays and had six cavities filled. They were so small that I did not need a single anaesthetic injection. The dentist also said I did not have a “cracked tooth” but a chipped one at the back and that unless it was causing a problem, which it wasn’t, it could be left as it was. The total price for this treatment was R2 461.

“Dr Greeff,” I went on, “the only reasonable conclusion I believe anybody would come to based on my experience with you; what my medical aid had to say and the work done by the dentist I saw after you, would be that you were trying to take an old man’s medical aid for a very expensive ride. You were ignoring the fact I would have been responsible for any shortfall in my medical aid’s payment and I would also have had to put up with all the unnecessary treatment that included local anaesthetics and possibly making several visits to you.

“You might like to know that I am a former Sunday Times investigative journalist turned Private Eye (before I retired) who has had considerable experience investigating medical malpractice. One of my cases resulted in a book. So I don’t believe that the allegations I am making against you are without considerable substance.

“Please let me know if you feel my accusations are unjust.”

I heard nothing from Dr Greeff until I had sent a similar email to Dr Francois de Manielle, one of the two directors of Dentalwise that is described as a “family orientated” private practice with surgeries in Durbanville, Sun Valley and Protea Heights (both in Cape Town), Belville, Atlantis, Somerset West and Worcester in the Western Cape.

This was when Dr Greeff made the following startling admissions with my comments in brackets. “An estimate is just that, a guess on the extent of the treatment that might be required as discussed during the consultation. If for example I start with a treatment, like a filling , there may be factors  that change such as the size of the filling, use of different relevant materials, use for local anaesthetics, use of isolation dams, requirement for additional radiographs ect.”

He then highlighted the following in his email (the highlighting in the section above is mine): “Therefore we tend to overquote when seeking authorisation from the medical aid but only charge for the actual treatment once it is done. The charge amount is always less than or the same as the quote depending on the given clinical situation. In fact it has become common practice for me to do free/discounted treatment because I am passionate about giving the treatment my patients actually need instead of what their medical aid allows me to do. This in my opinion is the real topic that needs investigating”

This is what Dr de Manielle told me in his email reply to mine. “Thank you very much for your e-mail and the concerns that you shared with me. Any feedback of this nature helps us at Dentalwize to be proactive in our approach and to always be on the lookout as to how we can improve our business model.

“Dentalwize aims to supply high quality service to the general public at medical aid rates in order to make it an affordable option to everyone. Many practices nowadays charge well in excess of those tariffs and are not interested in helping the patient obtain authorisation from their medical aids, neither do they send the account electronically to the medical aid which leaves the member with a lot of paperwork and delay of payments.

“Your feedback allows me to do the necessary checks again and to be ever so watchful of the kind of impression it creates. We certainly strive as a Company to be meticulous in doing a proper consultation, not leaving anything to chance. Too many legal claims evolve around not discussing the full extend of the oral needs and the subsequent treatment proposed for fixing that. In saying that, I would like to remind myself that this should not lead to overtreatment which I honestly doubt would have been Dr Greeff’s intentions.

“I sincerely thank you for raising your concerns; this has given me the opportunity to address this matter not only with the Dentists in particular, but on a more comprehensive scale throughout our entire business.”

Regards

Jon

P.S. You know what us old codgers have to say about our teeth: “Fangs ain’t what they used to be” and that probably applies to dentistry as well. 






 

        

 

 

 

        

 

Saturday, January 1, 2022

GOOD LORD DESMOND TUTU IS BEING REMEMBERED ON TV DURING HIS FUNERAL AMONG SOME OF THE MOST GRUESOME TRUE CRIMES IMAGINABLE

 Dear Readers,

         Is what DStv has been doing acceptable or in very bad taste?

         In its enthusiasm to honour Tutu it has put an RIP message on the top right hand side of the picture on a few of its channels. But the BIG QUESTION IS: Was it acceptable to have the name of this revered Bishop associated with True Crime murderers of women and children, serial killers and just about every other kind of horror story imaginable?

         On its 171 Discovery ID channel we are being shown blood curdling stories with titles like American Monster and The Lake Erie Murders. If these are not enough to scare the hell out of you there is Death North about a couple suspected of cutting up a guy and cooking him for lunch. For a bit of light relief In Pursuit with John Walsh tells us about how a doctor specialised in sexually molesting his female patients.

         All these have this message for the Arch on them: RIP Desmond Tutu 1931-2021.

From "Evil Lives here"
         I flicked through the various other channels at random and very few had this Tutu message on them.  Every business thrives on attracting attention, but is this the best way of doing it at a time of the world mourning for our one and only Arch? I don’t think so.

         When Tutu was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1984 I can’t believed that he would have been able to maintain his renowned sense of humour if DStv had chosen to keep repeating this in amongst the terror and debauchery that are on the channel where his RIP keeps popping up now.

         “You may have a point but we took a decision to pay tribute to him across our channels irrespective of what is being broadcast,” Calvo Mawela the CEO of MultiChoice, the owners of DStv told me. “I think he deserves to be remembered across the platform and it will be a reminder of good over evil.”

         Tragically no amount of prayers or anything else it seems are able to curb South Africa’s own TRUE CRIME which is spiraling out of control.

         Having done so much to oppose the White Apartheid Government Tutu must have been terribly disappointed with its replacement. It’s Black alright but so corrupt that every semblance of a modern society is collapsing around it to the detriment of most of us while the fats cats with their hands in the National till go unpunished.

Cyril hasn't always been blind
folded but he might as well
 have been

         In his ivory tower our President Cyril Ramaphosa keeps mum, just as he did when he sat beside the corrupt Jacob Zuma when he was the President who sold the country to the Gupta brothers. Cyril was his deputy from 2014 to 2018.

         Resting in Peace does have its advantages particularly in South Africa right now. Go well Arch.

         Regards Jon

         P.S. Here's what Tutu had to say when I asked him to comment on my 2011 post about him being called a "Black Nazi Pig" when he visited Israel to investigate its human rights abuses against the Palestinians. "It's hilarious, barbed and very clever. Thanks for your piece on the on-going saga of being anti-Semitic when one points out wrongs of not Jewish people, but of the Israeli Government. Ah well. Love and blessings to you and your Gayle. Arch"





    
  

 

 

Sunday, November 28, 2021

THE "SCIENTIFIC" COVID GUESSING GAME THAT IS DESTROYING THE WORLD

 Dear Readers,

Joe Phaahla South Africa's
Minister of Health

The Covid world panic has been a paradise for the ‘‘it might happen;’’, “it could make current vaccines ineffective;” “it’s better to be safe than sorry;” scientific scare mongers who have been making a name for themselves by destroying economies and putting millions of people out of work.

None of them have had any regard for the fact that the lock down cure hasn’t worked anywhere as they appear on TVs around the world egging on the panic with more and more stories of new and more deadly waves that “might do this” and “might do that”. This is the new science.

Meanwhile they conveniently ignore the cases and death stats that show that out of a world population of 8-B there have been a mere 261-M Covid cases with just 5-M deaths. That’s in a world where less than half the population has been vaccinated. What are these as a percentage of the number of people? I’m afraid I’m not scientific enough to be able to guess the answer to that.  

But in reality it’s like having a single fly in the sky that the scientists tell us is spreading a deadly disease in the atmosphere and that unless we all take cover we will die.

Britain has just helpfully branded South Africa and other countries in the region the polecats of the universe just in time to completely wreck the Xmas tourist season for our hotel groups and other tourist dependent organisations. Many of them were already on their knees thanks to all this “scientific information” about Covid.

As a “precautionary measure” Britain has overnight banned travel to and from South Africa and other countries in the region because of a new Covid variant that South Africa has been blamed for being the first country to have, even though cases have been popping up in Europe more or less at the same time. And “theoretically it can’t be prevented by any known vaccine.” Other countries around the world are falling over themselves to get in line with the British move. 



Joe Phaahla South Africa’s Minister of Health described the bans as “knee-jerk reactions” which didn’t make any scientific sense.

The bad joke is that the unvaccinated are being told to vaccinate while at the same time the scientists are saying that the current vaccines are unlikely to protect them against the new variant. How can they possibly conclude this when the new variant was only discovered very recently?



Is Covid science a series of guesses based on the scientific discovery that if you make enough of them one is bound to be right? The trouble is that governments around the world have now been so conditioned by the Covid panic that they react to the latest guess in the only way they know how with various versions of lock down.

Has anybody yet heard any of these top scientists telling us on TV about how many people are currently dying from aids, TB and numerous other diseases?  Tuberculosis has been described as a global pandemic that kills more people than malaria and Aids combined, but has there ever been a lock down anywhere because of this?

For those of you who still have a job "guess" what’s going to happen next. You’ll have to ask one of those Covid scientists who are never likely to lose their jobs as long as they can go on scaring the hell out of all of us.

Regards,

Jon, a Consumer Watchdog who has had both Pfizer jabs after I heard scientists “guess” that I would be protected. Then I saw on Google Pfizer is just as unreliable as any of these “scientific guesses” because it is run by crooks. This multinational US pharmaceutical company has a shocking record of dishonesty on a massive scale. This is how Pfizer’s shameful record since 2002 has been described: “Pfizer has been a ‘habitual offender’, persistently engaging in illegal and corrupt marketing practices, bribing physicians (to prescribe their drugs) and suppressing adverse trial results. The company and is subsidiaries have been assesses $3 billion in criminal convictions, civil penalties and jury awards.” Have you ever heard any of these “reliable” scientists that appear on TV tell us that we should keep clear of the Pfizer vaccine because the company has a terrible record of dishonesty. Of course you haven’t with the result that the Pfizer vaccine has been used to immunise huge numbers of people around the globe against Covid. A lot of members of Congress in the USA are said to own Pfizer shares, which tells its own story.

P.S. My wife and I have belatedly got a very old Covid variant. We are sick to almost death of hearing about Covid in every day and night TV news bulletin and reading about it in the media.