Dear Readers,
|
Pieter Boone Pick n Pay's new CEO |
In
spite of the appalling history of Johnson & Johnson’s (J&J) baby powder
Pick n Pay the South African 1945 store grocery chain has no intention of discontinuing
to stock this giant US pharmaceutical company’s product.
“We
assure you that the talcum powder has been approved by the relevant authorities
in South Africa,”
Mary-Anne Hattingh Pick n Pay’s National Customer Service Manager told me. I wonder what sort of endorsement that is.
For
something like 50 years J&J was endangering the lives of it’s customers by selling talc,
including baby powder of all things that contained asbestos that has been shown
to cause women ovarian cancer.
As far back as 1973 the firm rejected the advice of its own scientists
to replace the asbestos containing talc it was using with cornstarch. Like most
big companies profit came before saving people’s lives as the talc was cheaper
than the alternative.
Now the Supreme Court in America
has told J&J to pay heavily for its greed. It rejected the company’s appeal
against an award of $2.1 billion in damages because its powder products caused
women ovarian cancer.
Ken Starr, a former prosecutor representing the women with
cancer, urged the justices not to review the case saying that the firm had
known “for decades that its talc powders contained asbestos, a highly
carcinogenic substance with no known safe exposure level.”
After I tried to contact Pick n Pay’s new CEO Pieter Boone
I got Mary-Anne Hattingh instead and then quite unsolicited I received an email
from somebody named only as Joy from J&J’s Consumer Services. This is what
she told me:
“We empathize with anyone suffering from cancer and
understand that people are looking for answers. We believe these can be better
understood through science – and decades of independent scientific studies by
medical experts around the world shows that our talc is safe, does not contain
asbestos and does not cause cancer.
“We understand that lawsuits in the United States
and media headlines have caused confusion about our products and we are
committed to ensuring the facts are understood. The science supporting the
safety of our product is central to why our Company continued to defend itself
in court.”
She admitted that J&J had
discontinued the sale of its talc-based baby powder in the US and Canada, but claimed this had
nothing to do with its safety. “It was rather to address declining demand in North America due in large part to changes in consumer
habits fuelled by misinformation around the safety of the product through a
constant barrage of litigation advertising”, she went on. Presumably this was
to trace the people who claimed to have got cancer. She added that they do not offer a cornstarch-based product
in South Africa,
but its talc based baby powder is available and continues to be sold in other
markets around the world.
In a follow-up email she described the headlines I had been
reading as “concerning” and again emphasised that their powder was “safe”.
I replied: “This is very strange.
How did various women manage to get a compensation judgement for billions
against J&J because they claimed to have got ovarian cancer
from its powder and when this went to appeal it was dismissed? That’s what I
read on Google. If this is total fiction it must be one of the biggest
fabricated stories of the century. What you keep telling me to read appears to
be all about what J&J is claiming for its powder, not an independent
assessment. And for you to describe the headlines I have been reading as ‘concerning’
must be the understatement of the decade considering you represent J&J.
What really stands out is that at no stage have you told me that there is
absolutely no truth in the ‘concerning headlines’ that I have been reading.”
J&J’s already tarnished reputation
over the cancer claims took another serious knock when it was among the drug
companies that a group of US attorneys general obtained a $26bn settlement with
for fuelling the deadly nationwide opioid epidemic. They were accused of lax
controls that allowed a massive amount of addictive painkiller to be diverted
into illegal channels, thus devastating communities. J&J was said to have
down played the addiction risk in its marketing.
All
the companies denied the allegations. Attorneys general from 15 states were
involved in negotiating the deals and the money will be used for addiction
treatment, family support and efforts to eradicate the scourge of drug
addiction.
The bulk of the money will be paid by
the three largest US
distributors over 18 years with J&J paying $5-bn over nine years $3.7-bn of
which has to be settled in the first three.
“There’s not enough money in the world
frankly to address the pain and suffering caused,” said the Connecticut attorney general William Tong.
With its history of serious unethical behaviour how can J&J be
trusted to provide safe Covid vaccines to South Africa and the world? Will it
be cutting corners to save money once again or will it have learnt its lesson.
Unfortunately we will only find out the answer after millions of
people will have received the J&J one dose jab.
Barron’s the American financial magazine listed J&J
among its World’s Most Admired Companies and Fortune Magazine has included it
in its list of World’s Most Respected Companies. I wonder where it will come now after these scandals.
Alex Gorsky J&J’s Chairman and
CEO was named one of the 100 most Inspired Leaders by Pharma Voice. He joined J&J,
this 131 year old firm in 1988 and has headed it since 2012 so he deserves a
great deal of the blame for what happened under his nose to a baby powder that
has been in shops around the world. And the same goes for his firm’s dubious
painkiller marketing.
Regards,
Jon, a Consumer Watchdog who is
always sniffing out funny business that needs exposing.
P.S. It’s absolutely deplorable the way huge
companies that are often leaders in their field think about nothing else other
than making a profit, even if it means devastating the lives of their
customers. As this case proved BIG BUSINESS, far too often, doesn’t have the
morals of an alley cat.
P.P.S. A few weeks ago, before I became aware
of the background, I tried to buy some J&J baby powder in Pick n Pay and I
was told there was no stock. I was mystified as to why they would not have such
a well known brand. But as it turned out there was no question of Pick n Pay no
longer stocking it because when I was there a couple of days ago the shelves
were full of it.