Dear Readers,
In
spite of the fact that it is well known that hair is quite a sensitive subject
for Black women, Volkswagen has chosen to screen an advert on DStv that shows a
Black woman being belittled about her hair by her hairdresser, in front of an audience
of several concerned women in the salon.
This
has been done to promote the totally unrelated subject of Volkswagen’s service
plan.
It made its debut digitally in April and started airing on
TV in August this year. It is still appearing. Unlike the TRESemme` hair care one
that caused such a storm, this ad does not come across as obviously racist,
although some might argue that they would not have filmed a white women being
treated in the same way.
It consists of a Black woman sitting in a chair in a salon
while her Black hairdresser is doing her hair. The conversation goes like this:
Hair Dresser (HD): What’s news, what’s news girl? I want to
hear everything.
Client (C): So I started a new job and ….
HD: And then…
C: Hmm?
HD: Did you do your hair recently?
C: Um,well. It was my sister’s wedding and you were busy, I had to make a
plan.
At about this point the hairdresser, clearly angry
because the woman had her hair done elsewhere, starts pulling the woman’s head
around and combing her hair roughly.
HD: Okay.
C: It was just one time.
The woman continues to be roughed up by the hair
dresser as a row of women sitting on chairs opposite her look on with concerned
looks on their faces.
HD: It’s fine.
C: I didn’t mean anything.
HD: I said it’s fine.
Man standing at a dryer: No it’s not fine.
C: Yno…..
Man: It’s not fine.
C: If only maintaining my hair was as easy as maintaining the value of my
Volkswagen. With EasyDrive vehicle plans you get service per schedule
from qualified Volkswagen experts. It
ends with the hairdresser pulling her head as roughly as ever to one side and
the client saying Hay!!
The Client started off looking relaxed and happy, but
her expression changed as she became increasingly alarmed at the way her head
was being pulled around and her hair was being was being very forcibly combed.
* * *
When I saw the ad on DStv I put three questions to Dr Robert
Cisek head of Volkswagen in
Dr Robert Cisek |
I phoned its head office in Uitenhage; said I was a journalist and asked to speak to Dr Cisek or his PA; or to be given their email addresses. I was told I could not have these and that I should send my inquiries to this email address: support@vwconnect.co.za .This turned out to be no support at all, although my emails were addressed to Dr Cisek.
After getting four “we’ll be in touch” emails with Andrew Shaw’s name on them, when I asked when I could expect a reply, I finally received the answers to my questions. I only got them after I threatened to write that Dr Cisek had no comment to make, unless he or some other senior person at Volkswagen responded by noon the following day.
They came from Andile Dlamini, Head of Group Communications, Volkswagen, SA. My first question was: “In view of the fact that it is well known that hair is quite a sensitive subject for Black women; what was the thinking that justified belittling a Black woman in a salon to advertise Volkswagen’s Service Plan?” The other two have been answered elsewhere in this post so it’s not necessary for me to repeat the actual questions.
Dlamini replied: “Volkswagen is aware of the public dialogues, debates and cultural sensitivities around the topic of hair. We believe, together with our creative partners, that our ‘EasyDrive’ advert depicts a universal insight around the relationship between hairdressers and their clients that has no attachment to any specific race, culture, gender or political view. The intended message behind the ad is not to claim that any particular hair type is difficult - or easy - to maintain, but rather what the relationship one has with their hairdresser can be. The ad draws a parallel between this relatable relationship and the one between our customers and service teams. It’s a story about ‘relationships’ and pride in one’s workmanship and the importance of ‘loyalty’ to people who care about their service.’
He added that they had had “No’ complaints about the ad.“As the People’s Car, Volkswagen believes in always putting people first and so we do not support or disseminate advertising messages that are derogatory to any culture, race, gender or group.”
DOES THIS APPLY TO THE ADVERTISEMENT
IN QUESTION? YOU BE THE JUDGE.
Regards,
Jon, a Consumer Watchdog.
P.S. If Volkswagen is not more
careful that freedom of speech advocate Julius Malema, and his EFFing
followers, could be DEMANDING free cars for every female member of their Party.
P.P.S. The TRESemme`ad row
resulted in 400 Clicks stores that stocked it having to close briefly, because
of widespread protests by the EFF.
P.P.P.S. This is what Mark Rayner the CEO of MultiChoice the owner of DStv had to say about this ad.